Caring for Loved Ones | Assisted Living Versus Home Care?

^{Photo by Thirdman}

When our loved ones age, we inevitably have to face the question of what to do with them with regard to care. Caring for loved ones is hard. For many, the ideal scenario is for them to age in a place where they find themselves in a familiar and comfortable environment.

Assisted Living Versus Home Care? 

This is where home care steps in, offering various services to support seniors in their daily lives. However, there are situations where assisted living facilities might be a better fit, providing practical assistance and a vibrant social environment. 

A significant advantage of assisted living is the enhanced security and supervision. These places are explicitly designed with the safety of your loved ones in mind, with very helpful features like grab bars in bathrooms, emergency call systems, and well-lit hallways. Staff is readily available to assist with mobility issues and prevent falls and accidents, the foremost concern for seniors living alone.

While home care may provide some assistance with daily activities, it may not offer the same level of constant monitoring. This can be a worry for families with loved ones who have cognitive decline or require frequent medication reminders. Assisted living facilities provide peace of mind, knowing that professional caregivers are present 24/7 to ensure the well-being of their residents.

Assisted living goes beyond providing basic needs like bathing, dressing, and medication management. These places have a comprehensive program in place, encompassing physical, emotional, and social well-being. Residents can benefit from on-site healthcare professionals, such as nurses and therapists, who can monitor health conditions and provide necessary medical care.

Furthermore, assisted living communities often have a robust social calendar, with activities and events designed to stimulate minds, encourage socialization, and combat feelings of isolation. These activities, from exercise classes and art therapy sessions to movie nights and game nights, provide a sense of purpose and enjoyment. Research has shown that social interaction is crucial for older adults’ cognitive health and overall well-being. Home care might need to be able to replicate the same level of social engagement while offering companionship from caregivers.

Considerations in Caring for Loved Ones

For seniors who are living alone, loneliness and social isolation can be very daunting situations. Assisted living fosters a strong sense of community, allowing residents to connect with like-minded individuals with similar experiences and interests. This social interaction can significantly improve mental and emotional wellness. Many assisted living facilities organize group outings and trips, allowing residents to explore their surroundings and create lasting memories. This can starkly contrast with home care, where social interaction might be limited to caregiver visits.

Daily chores like cooking, cleaning, and laundry can become burdensome for seniors, especially those with declining physical abilities. Assisted living alleviates these burdens by providing housekeeping and meal services. This frees up residents’ time and energy to pursue hobbies, engage in social activities, or relax and enjoy their retirement.

Home care can offer some assistance with chores, but the responsibility often falls on the shoulders of the seniors or their family members. Assisted living allows seniors to relinquish these responsibilities, fostering a sense of independence and allowing them to focus on what truly matters to them. Many offer different levels of care, from independent living with minimal assistance to memory care units for those with dementia. This allows for a personalized care plan that adapts to the resident’s changing needs.

A Balanced Equation

Home care services may need to be adjusted over time, but the level of customization might not be as comprehensive as what assisted living facilities can offer. With a dedicated staff and a range of services under one roof, assisted living provides a flexible and adaptable care environment.

The cost of assisted living is often a significant concern for families. However, it’s essential to consider the value proposition it offers. The cost typically includes housing, meals, utilities, personal care services, activities, and sometimes even primary medical care. Compared to home care, where services can add up quickly, assisted living might be a more cost-effective solution, especially for seniors requiring a higher level of care management. 

Deciding the method in caring for loved ones is highly personal. There’s no one-size-fits-all answer. It depends on the individual’s needs, preferences, and financial situation. 

If you’ve questions about the decision, One Caregiver’s Journey, a book about life as a caregiver, is a great resource to help you on your way!